30 Best Scary Halloween Recipes from Spooky to Gross

Hannah Healy

By Hannah Healy

Updated August 13, 2024

This post may contain affiliate links. As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases. Please read the disclosure policy.

Pin
Share
Yum
Flip
Reddit
Tweet

These scary Halloween recipes are all treats, no tricks! Picture the fun as you whip up spooky face meat pies or monstrous cupcakes with googly eyes and green frosting. From savory meal ideas to sweet treats, these recipes are a playful spin on the classics, making Halloween potluck ideas a blast for busy home cooks. Whether you’re a fan of little ghosties or just love make-ahead treats, these festive spooky season dishes are sure to bring a bit of a fright to all your party guests!

Forget Me Not Cupcakes

Cupcakes topped with green sprinkles and realistic-looking edible fingers, arranged on a dark surface with a bowl containing more edible fingers.
Forget Me Not Cupcakes. Photo credit: The Simple-Sweet Life.

Looking for a delightfully spooky Halloween treat? These zombie cupcakes are sure to satisfy even the scariest sweet tooth!
Get the Recipe: Forget Me Not Cupcakes

Scary Halloween Eyeball Punch

Tall glass filled with red liquid and floating eyeball-shaped items, garnished with similar items on a skewer. Glistening black rim. Other identical glasses and a decorative spider in the background.
Halloween Eyeball Punch. Photo credit: xoxoBella.

This Halloween eyeball punch is a great way to kick off your Halloween party! It’s a Halloween punch recipe that is perfect for a crowd.
Get the Recipe: Halloween Eyeball Punch

Creepy Intestines Halloween Appetizer

A rectangular white platter displays a food item shaped like intestines covered in a red sauce, garnished with fake black spider decorations.
Creepy Intestines Halloween Appetizer. Photo credit: Aleka’s Get Together.

A creepy, gruesome Halloween appetizer that’s simple to make and just as delicious as it is gross! Perfect for your next Halloween party!
Get the Recipe: Creepy Intestines Halloween Appetizer

Bloody Eyeball Jello Shots

Six cups of chocolate pudding each topped with a candy eyeball, set on a table with black and red fabric and fake black spiders.
Bloody Eyeball Jello Shots. Photo credit: Jello Joy.

Once you get past the gross factor and taste these eyeball jello shots, you’ll love them! Even kids enjoy the alcohol-free version! The flavors of cherry jello, dark spiced rum, and coke mixed are so hard to resist! 
Get the Recipe: Bloody Eyeball Jello Shots

Halloween Mummy Meatloaf

A dish designed to resemble a face using bacon strips for skin, olives for eyes, and garlic cloves for teeth, placed on a black tray.
Halloween Mummy Meatloaf. Photo credit: Three Olives Branch.

Mummy Meatloaf is a perfect Halloween dinner idea! Savory ground beef meatloaf with bacon served on mashed potatoes.
Get the Recipe: Halloween Mummy Meatloaf

Halloween Lychee Eyeball Punch

A glass of red beverage with eyeball-shaped objects floating in it is displayed against a purple cloth background, accompanied by a bowl with similar contents, flowers, a rat figure, and a skull.
Halloween Lychee Eyeball Punch. Photo credit: Jello Joy.

Sweet and exotic, this gory Halloween punch has lychees and dark sweet cherries, lemon-lime soda (or lemonade), and jello for a lusciously rich mouthfeel.
Get the Recipe: Halloween Lychee Eyeball Punch

Spooky Face Meat Pie For Halloween

A pie with a face design, featuring dark fillings and a crust shaped like facial features, with an unsettling and eerie appearance. It is placed on a wooden mat beside a red cloth and a knife.
Spooky Face Meat Pie For Halloween. Photo credit: Maple Wood Road.

Looking for Halloween dinner ideas? Make this Spooky Face Meat Pie! Enjoy baking a creepy-looking face with all edible ingredients. 
Get the Recipe: Spooky Face Meat Pie For Halloween

Halloween Monster Mash Party Mix

A bowl filled with colorful Halloween-themed snacks including fake eyeballs, vampire teeth candy, various colored popcorn, chocolate-covered raisins, pretzels, and almonds.
Halloween Monster Mash Party Mix. Photo credit: The Forked Spoon.

This Halloween Monster Mash Party Mix is the perfect blend of creepy and fun! With candy eyeballs, gummy worms, chocolate, and pretzels, it’s an easy way to bring some spooky spirit to your Halloween snacks. Whip it up in five minutes for your next party, or pack it into gift bags for a sweet treat for friends and teachers!
Get the Recipe: Halloween Monster Mash Party Mix

Purple People Eater Drink

A glass with a skeleton hand design filled with a purple fizzy drink, topped with ice and a lychee. A candelabra and dark decor are in the background.
Purple People Eater Drink. Photo credit: Sweet Tea And Thyme.

Get into the Halloween spirit with this purple people eater drink! This spooky mocktail or cocktail is perfect for a monster-themed party.
Get the Recipe: Purple People Eater Drink

Swamp Eggs

Close-up of blue marbled egg halves filled with green mashed vegetable filling, garnished with seeds, arranged artfully on a dark surface.
Swamp Eggs. Photo credit: An Edible Mosaic.

Halloween deviled eggs look like something that came out of the swamp! This is an easy method for making crackled, naturally dyed, deviled eggs.
Get the Recipe: Swamp Eggs

Spooky Halloween Sangria

A close-up of a dark red beverage in a glass, garnished with fruit, lychees, and a sprig of rosemary.
Spooky Halloween Sangria. Photo credit: Sweet Tea And Thyme.

Get into the Halloween spirit with this spooky Halloween Sangria! It’s an easy recipe that mixes red wine, fruit, and apple cider to create the perfect Halloween drinks for any party.
Get the Recipe: Spooky Halloween Sangria

Halloween Puking Pumpkin With Guacamole

A carved pumpkin with eyes and a mouth appears to be vomiting guacamole, which is surrounded by tortilla chips on a platter.
Halloween Puking Pumpkin With Guacamole. Photo credit: I Heart Naptime.

Make a Halloween-punk pumpkin with guacamole as this year’s Halloween party centerpiece! It’s a fun and easy appetizer.
Get the Recipe: Halloween Puking Pumpkin With Guacamole

Witches’ Fingers Scary Halloween Cookies

A tray of finger-shaped cookies with red jelly and almond slivers, resembling severed fingers, on a yellow and black patterned napkin.
Witches’ Fingers Scary Halloween Cookies. Photo credit: Christina’s Cucina.

Witches’ fingers are scary Halloween cookies that look terrible but taste great! Try them and see how many are brave enough to eat these horrible hand-looking snacks!
Get the Recipe: Witches’ Fingers Scary Halloween Cookies

Graveyard Pudding Cups For Halloween

Clear cups of chocolate pudding topped with crushed cookies, decorated with tombstone-shaped toppers and skulls, resembling graveyard dirt cups, on a black surface.
Graveyard Pudding Cups For Halloween. Photo credit: Finding Zest.

Graveyard Pudding Cups are a perfect Halloween dessert! They feature an easy chocolate mousse topped with crumbled brownies and edible gravestones.
Get the Recipe: Graveyard Pudding Cups For Halloween

Halloween Panna Cotta Eyeballs

Close-up of Halloween-themed dessert with white pudding shaped like an eyeball, topped with red syrup and black spider decoration, placed on a glass dish with skeletal hand props around it.
Halloween Panna Cotta Eyeballs. Photo credit: xoxoBella.

There is no shortage of gross-looking Halloween food, but these panna cotta eyeballs are extra gross! This dessert that looks like eyeballs is the best Halloween party food idea for adults and kids.
Get the Recipe: Halloween Panna Cotta Eyeballs

Halloween Antipasto Eyeballs Appetizer

A tray of ham slices arranged with olives and cheese to resemble eerie eyes, placed on parchment paper with a pair of glasses nearby. Black toy spiders are scattered around the arrangement.
Halloween Antipasto Eyeballs Appetizer. Photo credit: xoxoBella.

This Halloween mozzarella eyeball appetizer combines a variety of wonderful Italian flavors in every mouthful.
Get the Recipe: Halloween Antipasto Eyeballs Appetizer

Halloween Bruschetta Appetizer

Close-up of toast topped with skull-shaped mozzarella on tomato sauce, surrounded by garnishes of basil leaves and black spiders, presented in a Halloween-themed setting.
Halloween Bruschetta Appetizer. Photo credit: xoxoBella.

This Halloween bruschetta appetizer features black pesto and skull-shaped mozzarella balls. It’s a tasty Italian appetizer with Halloween flavors.
Get the Recipe: Halloween Bruschetta Appetizer

Monster Pumpkin Cheesecake Bites

Close-up of chocolate truffles decorated as monsters with edible eyes and sprinkles on a wooden surface.
Monster Pumpkin Cheesecake Bites. Photo credit: Little Nomad Recipes.

When it comes to Halloween food ideas, these Pumpkin Cheesecake Bites are the best! With a creamy mix of pumpkin puree, cream cheese, and pumpkin spice covered in dark chocolate, they hit the right spot for Halloween treats. For a grown-up twist, skip the eyes and sprinkles and just add a sprinkle of pumpkin spice powder on top.
Get the Recipe: Monster Pumpkin Cheesecake Bites

Eyeball Deviled Eggs Recipe

Deviled eggs with green and yellow fillings, decorated to resemble eyeballs with red food coloring veins and candy eyes, arranged on a black tray.
Eyeball Deviled Eggs Recipe. Photo credit: Happy Foods Tube.

Try this eyeball-deviled egg recipe for a Halloween party with a spooky effect! These delicious appetizers are super easy to make and can be prepped ahead of time.
Get the Recipe: Eyeball Deviled Eggs Recipe

Spooky Halloween Mimosa With Bloody Rim

Two tall glasses filled with a red liquid, adorned with silver skeleton hand holders, sit next to a white skull on a dark table with a twigs backdrop.
Spooky Halloween Mimosa With Bloody Rim. Photo credit: Sweet Tea And Thyme.

Learn how to make a Halloween mimosa! This spooky Halloween cocktail recipe is made with champagne and dressed up with a bloody rim.
Get the Recipe: Spooky Halloween Mimosa With Bloody Rim

Cake Ball Brains Oozing Cherry Blood

A dessert shaped like a brain with a white exterior and a dark red filling oozing out, served on a white plate against a green background. "Hungry Happenings" text is visible in the bottom right corner.
Cake Ball Brains Oozing Cherry Blood. Photo credit: Hungry Happenings.

Looking for easy Halloween recipes that’ll have everyone talking? Make some Creepy Halloween Sweets this year and try these Cake Ball Brains with Oozing Cherry Blood! This fan favorite is absolutely to die for. 
Get the Recipe: Cake Ball Brains Oozing Cherry Blood

Creature from the Deep Tentacle Cupcakes

Three chocolate cupcakes with gray frosting topped with tentacle decorations, displayed on a black square stand against a dark background.
Creature from the Deep Tentacle Cupcakes. Photo credit: Tikkido.

These easy, creepy Creatures from the Deep cupcakes are the perfect treat to make for Halloween. The tentacle cupcake toppers are made from gum paste, so they’re edible!
Get the Recipe: Creature from the Deep Tentacle Cupcakes

Halloween Charcuterie Board

A Halloween-themed charcuterie board features an array of meats, cheeses, crackers, fruits, and chocolates, creatively arranged around a small plastic skeleton. Decor includes fake spiders and cobwebs.
Halloween Charcuterie Board. Photo credit: Aleka’s Get Together.

This Halloween charcuterie board is a delicious and nutritious family-friendly appetizer or snack that’s just as much fun to assemble as it is to serve! With ghostly string cheese, dark berries, and spider-guarded black olives, it’s the perfect side for an October scary movie night! 
Get the Recipe: Halloween Charcuterie Board

Halloween Candy Bark With Oreo Cookies

A plate of Halloween-themed chocolate bark covered with white frosting, colorful sprinkles, and candy decorations resembling pumpkins and other festive shapes.
Halloween Candy Bark With Oreo Cookies. Photo credit: Chenee Today.

This easy Halloween White Chocolate Bark with Oreo cookies hits the sweet spot for the spooky season! It’s one of my favorite festive Halloween recipes that everyone in the family loves. Get ready for some fun with this Halloween candy bark!
Get the Recipe: Halloween Candy Bark With Oreo Cookies

Spooky Halloween Skull Potatoes

Skewered Halloween-themed meatballs on a wooden board, accompanied by a bowl of red dipping sauce, on a mesh tablecloth with skeleton hand decorations and scattered shredded paper.
Spooky Halloween Skull Potatoes. Photo credit: xoxoBella.

Looking for a spooky snack that’s a total scream? Check out these Halloween skull potatoes! They’re the perfect Halloween side dish or appetizer to add a scare factor to your celebrations. These shrunken-head spooky potatoes go great with any meal and will definitely be a big hit. Don’t forget to grab the recipe card!
Get the Recipe: Spooky Halloween Skull Potatoes

Easy Cookie Monster Cookies Recipe

Blue-green cookies with white and dark chocolate chips and candy eyes scattered on top and around them on a parchment-lined surface.
Easy Cookie Monster Cookies Recipe. Photo credit: Chenee Today.

These easy Halloween treats for kids are a total blast! The blue cookie monster cookies, stuffed with chocolate chips, Oreo chunks, and melty milk chocolate, are a creative way to make your Halloween party much fun.
Get the Recipe: Easy Cookie Monster Cookies Recipe

Scary Jack-O-Lantern Pumpkin Cupcakes For Halloween

Two cupcakes with bright orange frosting designed as Jack-o'-lantern faces with black icing on a checkered tablecloth.
Scary Jack-O-Lantern Pumpkin Cupcakes For Halloween. Photo credit: Kim Schob.

Can’t decide which Halloween-themed food to try this year? Make these Halloween cupcakes with fun Jack-O-Lantern faces and cool, bright pumpkin orange frosting.
Get the Recipe: Scary Jack-O-Lantern Pumpkin Cupcakes For Halloween

Halloween Mini Pizza Ideas For Kids

Three decorated mini pizzas on a cutting board: one with a funny face made of cheese and olives, one with random cheese stripes, and one resembling a lion with yellow pepper mane and pepperoni face.
Halloween Mini Pizza Ideas For Kids. Photo credit: The Feathered Nester.

Looking for fun Halloween food ideas for kids? Your little ghouls and goblins will love this spooktacular Halloween dish! Make mini pizzas with scary ghosts, spiders, and mummies.
Get the Recipe: Halloween Mini Pizza Ideas For Kids

No-Bake Cheesecake Pumpkin Truffles

A wooden surface displays white chocolate truffles decorated with red spots and white drizzles, resembling eyeballs, next to a fake spider and black mesh décor.
No-Bake Cheesecake Pumpkin Truffles. Photo credit: Kim Schob.

These beady-eyed cheesecake pumpkin truffles are perfect for Halloween! This no-bake recipe takes no time to whip up and is loads of fun to decorate!
Get the Recipe: No-Bake Cheesecake Pumpkin Truffles

Spider Web Pretzel Snacks

A Halloween-themed treat featuring pretzel sticks arranged in a spider web pattern, drizzled with white chocolate, colorful sprinkles, and a spider-shaped chocolate decoration at the center.
Spider Web Pretzel Snacks. Photo credit: Pam’s Daily Dish.

These spider web pretzel snacks are the perfect Halloween treat. A chocolate spider center is the hub of a white chocolate pretzel “web.”
Get the Recipe: Spider Web Pretzel Snacks

Here are some other posts you may enjoy:

30 Best Scary Halloween Recipes from Spooky to Gross
Pin
Share
Yum
Flip
Reddit
Tweet

Hannah Healy

Hannah Healy is the founder of Healy Eats Real, a health and wellness website that provides healthy recipes and helpful information on wellness. Hannah is the published author of The Ultimate Paleo Cookbook. Her work has been featured on Huffington Post, Buzzfeed, Redbook, fitness and MSN.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.